Mohun Bagan president Swapan Sadhan Bose and general secretary Anjan Mitra had administered the club together but fell apart about a year ago.
The court had also suggested that the two groups sit together and decide on a person to hold the elections at the earliest, preferably by August.
Mahesh Tekriwal, a former executive member from Bose's group, had moved the high court praying for appointment of a special officer for conducting the election at the club.
Dutta opposed the plea and sought its rejection claiming that Mohun Bagan is a private club having its own constitution and that there has been no allegation of any serious mismanagement for the court to interfere.
He claimed that the club executive committee can hold the election by itself.
It was stated before the court that 12 members of the 20-member executive committee including Tekriwal had resigned on April 26.